In case you can’t tell, I’m passionate about rationality and critical thinking.

However, I still appreciate a freshly-baked π.

  • 0 Posts
  • 18 Comments
Joined 7 months ago
cake
Cake day: September 22nd, 2024

help-circle



  • I didn’t reach to find that era - it was referenced from the article, even the snippet at the top of this very page:

    But humanity had been free of current forms of advertising for 99.9% of its existence.

    Then you provided examples that occured within the most recent .1% sliver of humanity’s existence. Anything more recent than ~30,000 BCE is within that .1% time frame. Ergo, Ancient Rome doesn’t count.

    flowers advertising themselves to insects and birds advertising their singing abilities to each other.

    This is why it’s important to define terms before beginning debates. The advertising people are referencing here is the modern kind targeted at humans in order to manipulate them. To compare that to the symbiotic relationships between flowers and their pollinators, or to animals seeking a mate, (both scenarios that benefit all parties mutually) is a false equivalence.

    Anyway, I tried to keep things light-hearted in that last post, to show that I’m not looking to attack anyone. I gave you credit for providing a novel viewpoint, in an effort to build conversation. But I’m getting the impression that you’re not arguing in good faith. If you’d like have a real discussion, cool, I’m in. But if you’re looking for an argument, I recommend you look elsewhere.


  • The word “new” is a relative term. Humans evolved around 300,000 BCE, and ancient Rome (founded in 753 BCE) is pretty “new” by that metric. You’re not wrong that people found ways to “advertise” to each other throughout recorded history, but when it comes to prehistory (or as the article states, “99.9% of [humanity’s] existence”), life was very different. There can’t have been much to advertise before people developed tradable goods.

    With that said, I’m intrigued by your comprehensive interpretation of “advertising.” Now I’m wondering about things that would not have been written down/recorded, like things a town crier might have been incentivized to add to their announcements.

    “Hear ye, hear ye! A joust is to be held tomorrow evening in the royal courtyard, in the King’s honor. Sir and Lady Abbington announce the birth of their new son, to be baptized at the Lord’s church this Saturday. In celebration, Mavis the Fishmonger is offering a buy-one-get-one deal on all flounder! Come on down to the market square for fantastic deals on all your seafood goods - just look for the stall with the yellow awning. Get your catch of the day at Mavis’s!”



  • These policies work out for the business as well, especially when the store shares a plaza with a pet supply place.

    People bringing their dogs to store A might see store B and want to shop there, too. If store B bans pets, that means people either have to bring their dogs home and come back (which is a pain, and people might not return at all), or leave the dogs in their car (which is dangerous or even illegal.) Smart business people don’t want people leaving without shopping, and people with any sense of decency don’t want dogs left in cars.

    So when store B explicitly permits people to bring their pets, people can go straight there from Store A without worry. Customers are happy, dogs are happy, business people are happy, and no pets have to suffer in a locked vehicle.












  • Back when I used Reddit, one of my favorite subs was TrollX. If we had a sub with that spirit, it would be a good start.

    Are there secret communities on Lemmy? Not that secret communities should be a default, but I was invited to a secret sub on Reddit years ago that was all women. It was a true safe space from harrassment, where we could talk about feminine things that we knew wouldn’t gain traction in main subs. I have no idea how it started, but I knew that users who were invited to join had previously been vetted by the sub’s mods - they saw that I’d made feminist posts and multiple comments about being a woman, and didn’t go around picking fights. It was like a background check.

    I don’t believe there is any one solution, but starting with dedicated communities (in the spirit of TrollX), with mods that smack down misogyny and (actual) trolls, sounds like the best way to start.