• 0 Posts
  • 44 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 9th, 2023

help-circle











  • Yes, it’s censorship. But censorship isn’t inherently bad or wrong. Go join an LGBTQ community, and start saying trans slurs. Go to a group for renewable energy discussion, and start talking about how great diesel trucks are. You would be banned, and rightly so, because censorship (aka. moderation) is necessary to protect the group from bad actors.

    What becomes problematic is when those with vast amounts of power get to decide what everyone is allowed to say for considerations other than group safety or topical relevance. What people usually mean when they say “censorship” is “moderation without reasonable justification.” Folks like Musk routinely censor anyone who’s critical of his ideals, his friends, or holds beliefs counter to his own.

    So as you consider censorship, you need to keep in mind that there’s reasonable and unreasonable censorship, and it’s up to you to decide where that line is and recognize the potential baggage that line (or lack) comes with.

    Lack of censorship ≠ less harm.





  • But lately I’ve been in a rough state mentally (I say lately but it’s always been with me) and having GPT guide me and being able to just dictate what I think helps me a lot on various levels, for various reasons.

    You should consider journaling and/or a support group and/or professional help. You say it’s always been with you, and relying on an LLM to help you parse your thoughts is only going to lead to bad places. It does not have the knowledge or skill of a psychologist, even with its vast database. It doesn’t “know” the correct way to apply psychological concepts or know when you’re engaging in destructive behavior, and it could even reinforce those same behaviors. AI can feel like a friend to talk to, but it’s an illusion.

    But at this point, using ChatGPT with a mic, isn’t this basically cancelling every effort I’ve made? (using it in the first place anyway)

    If you’re telling it your deepest secrets and current problems, yes. You’re putting your personal information out there for a profit-driven company to use at their discretion. Several people have suggested self-hosting, and I would agree, but ultimately I think you need to seek human help for the root cause of why you’re leaning so heavily upon AI.


  • Large Language Models only learn and repeat patterns, I don’t think it’s a good tool for introspection, because it’s giving you more generic thoughts and only making it seem personal.

    Worse, it’s doing that lazily. People think that just because it has a gigantic database of information that it’s able to parse all that information and put together summaries of that sum total of information, but what it does in reality is find the first solution it can cobble together from anonymous internet sources and present that as an “answer.”

    Asking a generic code question about data structures is less likely to produce bad answers, since there’s little disagreement in how to implement them. They’re close to brute facts, and a wrong answer is rarely catastrophic. Asking it about psychology or philosophy, however, is prone to terrible answers, not just because there’s vast disagreement in those fields, but there’s also a lot of personal consideration when it comes to applying the information to individuals.



  • I have to admit I’m glad that Elon Musk & Donald Trump exist, to balance this crazy world of censorship

    Lol, yeah they’re totally free speech absolutists and not fascists who attack their political enemies and anyone who doesn’t kiss the ring. /s

    A funny meme, but sadly real…

    No, it’s not. The government isn’t scared of censoring lawful speech, regardless of how many guns we have. That’s a fantasy promoted by gun lovers with a hero complex. Look at how many protests to which they send goon squads. Also, average Americans have no idea what goes on in Europe. Americans are self-centered ignoramuses and think the entire world revolves around them.

    So Twitter ( aka X ) bought by Mr. Musk is a relieve. Apparently ( since they clean it ) a space with no, or less censorship Hooray !

    You can’t possibly be this naive. You’re trolling, right? Elon Musk is a Nazi. He routinely silences people he doesn’t like, especially anyone of note who calls out his bad behavior.

    So, I don’t understand , why the fuck, Twitter ban people that use TOR !? If they were really wanted the common good…

    Because they’re not. They don’t give two shits about the public good. Elon bought Twitter to influence elections; it’s his personal propaganda machine. I can’t believe you are this ignorant…

    Any way Twitter is a centralized platform and this is not good ! can’t wait to see a real decentralized place, kind like Lemmy, but Lemmy can be bring down too easily ! compare to an .onion

    No it can’t. Governments around the world would have to take each individual instance down. They can’t just ban Lemmy, because it’s not a single company.

    Also, Mastodon exists. Do some research on the Fediverse.