• 0 Posts
  • 8 Comments
Joined 2 months ago
cake
Cake day: June 18th, 2025

help-circle
  • Kind of reminds me of this beautiful poem:

    "…And I will leave. but the birds will stay, singing:

    and my garden will stay, with its green tree,

    and its white water well…

    Many afternoons the skies will be calm and blue,

    and the bells in the belfry will chime,

    like they’re chiming this very afternoon.

    The people who have loved me will die,

    and the town will burst anew every year.

    And in the corner of my green, flowering whitewashed garden,

    my spirit will wander nostalgic from tree to well.

    And I will leave,

    and I’ll be lonely, without a home,

    without a green tree, without a white water well,

    without calm and blue skies…

    And the birds will stay, singing."

    -“El viaje definitivo”, Juan Ramón Jiménez




  • AreaSIX @lemmy.ziptoHistory Memes@lemmy.worldAny Egyptologists confirm?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    7 days ago

    Wow, an American backing up the Aussie’s settler colonial understanding of national identity. What a shock that a member of the other major anglo settler colonial entity that hates the indigenous people of its land would feel this way. You are the anomaly, the rest of the world doesn’t distance itself from the history of the people who have lived there over the years. Understandable that you can’t relate though, your whole society has been based on the extermination of those people. So it’d be difficult to claim their history as your own or even feel a positive connection to it. That’s not the case for much of the rest of the world though.


  • AreaSIX @lemmy.ziptoHistory Memes@lemmy.worldAny Egyptologists confirm?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    7 days ago

    I know it’s sometimes hard for Aussies to imagine history beyond 300 years back as being relevant to your national identity. But that’s just because it’d make you face the fact that your nation is built upon the ruins of a civilisation you feel zero connection to, because of you know, you being colonial settlers and them being the indigenous people you tried (and still try) to eradicate. In Egypt, and indeed in Italy, Greece, Iran, China, India and so on, people don’t viscerally hate what came before them wanting to just forget them. They do often feel as the inheritors of those ancient civilizations, and have incorporated them into their own national identity. So yes, Italians do feel like the inheritors to the ancient Romans, just ask an Italian.


  • AreaSIX @lemmy.ziptoHistory Memes@lemmy.worldAny Egyptologists confirm?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    7 days ago

    That’s a very particular and odd view of what a civilisation is. By this logic, there are no inheritors to ancient Egypt at all since even the current inhabitants speak Arabic and not ancient Egyptian. In fact, Ancient Egyptian had already developed into Demotic Egyptian by the time of Cleopatra, and Demotic in itself was heavily influenced by Aramaic and, you guessed it, Greek. It’s fairly common for language to develop and change throughout the history of old civilisations, and in that process, be influenced by the major civilisations of the time. Cleopatra speaking Greek doesn’t make her not Egyptian, it just means that the Greeks were the dominant civilisation in her region during her lifetime. A thousad years later she’d be speaking Arabic, which still wouldn’t make her not Egyptian.